Table of Contents:
Where Hospital Systems are Today | Defining Hospital-based Emergency Care | Differentiating Hospital Capabilities | Important Considerations in Pediatric ED Care | Pediatric Readiness | Inter-facility Transfer Processes | ED Operations, Licensure, and Accreditation | EMSC Contributions to ED Hospital Care | Where Hospital Systems are Headed
A working knowledge of emergency departments (EDs) and the hospital/state systems in which they operate is essential information for Emergency Medical Services for Children (EMSC) program managers. Hospitals and emergency departmentsEDs are important components of the continuum of emergency care for children as defined by the EMSC Program. Thus EMSC managers are tasked with assuring that the needs of children are well integrated into this part of the emergency care system as well. This section will:
- describe important considerations in hospital emergency care in the U.S. focusing upon hospital capacity and capabilities, as well as licensing/accreditation processes influencing ED requirements;
- identify important partners to assist in leading and integrating essential pediatric emergency care components into hospital EDs in your state; and
- provide links to key resources to enhance one’s knowledge regarding the role of hospitals in the emergency care of children, as well as the achievement of the EMSC performance measures and overall improvement of ED readiness for pediatric patients.
|
Where Hospital Systems Are Today
|
[Back to: Top] |
ED care in the U.S. is strained. An ever-growing population coupled with a decline in the number of hospitals has led to overcrowding. Additionally, the ED often serves as the primary care provider for many and has become the safety net for those with no or inadequate insurance or poor access to primary or specialty care. This leads to high costs incurred by the ED with relatively low rates of reimbursement. Furthermore, overcrowding of the hospital often leads to boarding, or holding patients in the ED for extended periods of time until beds become available. Boarding creates numerous problems for the ED: lack of staff and lack of beds for those patients needing emergency care. A back-up in the entire emergency care system can then occur, often spilling over to EMS. Ambulances can be detained in busy EDs while waiting for an available room or may even be diverted from the facility altogether forcing transport of the patient to another facility. Definitive care is then prolonged and the transporting ambulance is then kept out-of-service which, in turn, prolongs response times to the next 9-1-1 call. These delays are often exacerbated for pediatric patients due to fewer, more distant facilities with pediatric beds or pediatric- trained medical staff. For more on access to pediatric specialty care, see the Pediatric Regionalization of Care Primer.
|
Defining Hospital-based Emergency Care
|
[Back to: Top] |
Hospital EDs and, increasingly, stand-alone emergency centers provide an array of urgent and emergent care services. Most EDs operate 24-hours a day, seven days a week and have immediate access to diagnostic services including diagnostic imaging and laboratory services. Large, high-volume EDs may care for thousands of patients a week and are staffed by highly-trained emergency providers and on-call specialists in almost every field. Smaller community hospitals often have more limited specializations immediately accessible, and some rural and frontier hospitals may depend on a local on-call physician for immediate stabilization and transfer to definitive care. In many communities, the ED also functions as primary care and may be the last resort for patients with no or limited insurance. Importantly, rural areas have the highest rate of ED visits at 502 per 1,000 population compared to 319 visits per 1,000 population in metropolitan counties.1
|
Differentiating Hospital Capabilities
|
[Back to: Top] |
Today, approximately 5,700 hospitals exist in the United States. According to the American Hospital Association (AHA), just over 3,000 are classified as urban community hospitals, 1,971 are rural community facilities, and the remainder are federal government facilities, psychiatric hospitals, and long-term care hospitals.2 Of these, more than 1,300 are designated as critical access hospitals (CAHs) and serve an important role in rural/frontier areas. CAHs are specially designated rural facilities that meet certain federal Medicare requirements; they must be located in states that have a rural health plan for the State Flex Program, maintain no more than 25 beds, furnish 24-hour emergency care services, and be 35 miles from any other hospital.3
Other classifications and systems of hospitals and ED care have evolved over time. Identification of time sensitive diagnoses has led most states to develop sophisticated systems of emergency care for these patients– i.e. trauma and perinatal systems. Recent time-sensitive systems developed in many states include stroke and cardiac, or STEMI,4 centers. It is important for EMSC managers to know and understand the systems of care that exist in their state, the requirements and the capabilities of hospitals participating in these systems, the lead agencies for these systems, and their potential impact on the emergency care of children. Each of these systems and the hospitals participating in the system bring resources that are potentially valuable to children. Though all systems, excluding perinatal, were developed originally for the adult patient, it is important to recognize that these systems provide validation of the need for advance preparations and specific requirements for facilities when providing care to high risk, low volume emergency patients. For most community hospital general EDs, critically ill and injured children are both low volume and at high risk, necessitating a system of care that assures initial capacity to provide appropriate care as well as access to resources, including processes for inter-facility transfer.
Summary of Common Hospital Types Providing Emergency Care for Children
| Hospital Type and Important Characteristics |
Number in U.S |
Categorization Responsibilities |
Care Provided to |
Critical Access Hospitals (CAH)
Primary hospital provider in rural/frontier locations.
>Located are least 35 miles from another community hospital.
>Staff available 24/7.
>Facilities have no more than 25 beds
>Average length of stay is less than 96 hours.
>Transfer agreements required to assure ability to move patients to additional care. |
1,331 |
Center for Medicare/Medicaid Services |
Community citizens |
Trauma centers are part of state tiered systems of care for the injured.
Pediatric Trauma Centers, Level I and II
Capabilities of each tier are often defined in state statute.
Transfer agreements are part of the essential criteria for all trauma centers as well as trained staff in trauma resuscitation and the collection of data for performance improvement. |
Level I = 190
Level II = 255
Level III = 258
Level IV number not available
Pediatric Trauma Centers - 170 |
States primarily regulate, though some states do not have state standards but utilize a voluntary process. American College of Surgeons may partner with states to verify trauma center capabilities. |
Severely injured patients |
Perinatal centers are also part of a tiered system for high risk mothers and babies and includes:
Level I – low risk
Level II – Specialty Care
Level III – Subspecialty Care
Level IV – Regional Resource Center |
Specialty Centers = 148
Subspecialty Care = 809
Resource Centers (NA*) |
States regulate |
Newborns and premature infants |
Burn centers
(May be stand-alone centers or part of a medical center.) |
127 |
American Burn Federation designates |
Severely burned adults and children |
(*NA – data not available. To learn more about hospital types and capabilities see "Hospital Types and Defining Characteristics" in the Pediatric Regionalization of Care Primer.)
|
Important Considerations in Pediatric ED Care
|
[Back to: Top] |
Important EMSC Side Note:
Specialty pediatric hospitals or children’s hospitals comprise only about 5% of all American hospitals and do not exist in every community or in every state. In response to the unevenness of pediatric emergency care resources, the EMSC Program established specific performance measures aimed at improving access to quality emergency care in EDs while assuring EDs are well prepared to provide an appropriate level of care for pediatric patients. PM #74 and #75 measure the percentage of hospitals with an ED recognized through a statewide, territorial, or regional standardized system that are able to stabilize and/or manage pediatric medical and trauma emergencies. Additionally, the EMSC performance measures #76 and #77 address inter-facility transfer guidelines and agreements; important considerations that should be planned proactively and available in every ED. See performance measures #74 – #76 in EMSC Performance Measures Implementation Manual for State Partnership Grantees.
|
EDs often serve as a gateway to definitive care through triage, assessment, stabilization, and transfer to the most appropriate resources, either internally within the hospital or inter-facility transfer to another hospital. The complexities of providing emergency care to children are a reflection of the unique physiological, psychosocial, and emotional needs of the pediatric patient. These unique considerations change regularly and often as the child grows and develops, thus impacting equipment and policies of care. It is also important to realize that children and adolescents access the emergency care system for different reasons than do adults. Pediatric patients have different diseases and injuries than adults, and many children will have chronic diseases necessitating frequent ED visits.Children comprise 27% of the U.S. population and account for approximately 20% of all hospital ED visits. They are often described as portable, presenting at their local community ED by private car, being brought in by a parent or caretaker, and not by ambulance. Data shows that 90% of emergency pediatric visits take place in a local general hospital rather than a facility with pediatric specialization or expertise. But few hospitals have all the specialty resources pediatric patients sometimes need and which often contribute to optimal outcomes of critically ill/injured children. The Institute of Medicine describes pediatric emergency care as being uneven in America as a result of the inequity of available pediatric care resources. Transfer of the pediatric ED patient to specialty facilities for children is thus common.
As early as 1996 professional organizations, recognizing the unique care needs of children, developed pediatric guidelines for EDs. These guidelines have been reviewed and revised over time incorporating consensus evidence. The most recent revision, Joint Policy Statement: Guidelines for Care of Children in the Emergency Department, authored by EMSC partners, the American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP), the American College of Emergency Physicians (ACEP), and the Emergency Nurses Association (ENA), has also been endorsed by 22 professional organizations. These guidelines serve as the foundation of essential components that should be available in every ED providing care to sick and injured children. Hospitals meeting these guidelines are often referred to as being “pediatric ready.”
|
Pediatric Readiness
|
[Back to: Top] |
Important EMSC Side Note:
Aggregate data for each state is displayed on the Pediatric Readiness website's State Results. Many State Partnership Programs also have the raw assessment data that can be further analyzed for QI and resource development. National focus on this project has brought forth many EMSC partners and champions who have expressed interest in providing support to hospitals. If your state has not focused much attention on your Pediatric Readiness data and efforts to increase hospital readiness scores, it may be an excellent opportunity to share your state data and forge partnerships with representatives of some or all of the following groups:
- State Departments of Hospital Licensure and Regulations, if one exists in your state
- State chapters of the national partners of this initiative: AAP, ACEP, and ENA
- State systems of care leaders specifically impacted by non-pediatric ready EDs, i.e. trauma managers/coordinators
- State disaster and hospital preparedness leaders
- State hospital association leadership
- Office of Rural Health, if large numbers of rural or frontier (CAH) community hospitals exist in your state
|
Recognizing that most children experiencing an emergency will be initially treated at a community ED, it is imperative that a foundation of care be assured for all children in every hospital ED. Guidelines for care of the pediatric patient in the ED were first drafted by the American Medical Association in 1996. In 2001, AAP and ACEP partnered to update these guidelines – Care of Children in the Emergency Department: Guidelines for Preparedness. In 2003, the federal EMSC Program provided funding for the Guidelines Project Steering Committee to conduct a survey of all U.S. hospitals to determine compliance with the 2001 Guidelines for Preparedness. Study results revealed that most hospitals were unaware of the national guidelines and few hospitals had all of the equipment in the recommended guidelines.
In 2009, AAP, ACEP, and ENA released the aforementioned Joint Policy Statement: Guidelines for Care of Children in the Emergency Department to replace the 2001 Guidelines for Preparedness. The joint statement offers recommendations for essential equipment, medications, personnel training, and key policies necessary for optimal pediatric emergency care. In the fall of 2012, the EMSC Program, in partnership with these organizations and the EMSC State Partnership grantees, initiated the Peds Ready is an ongoing quality improvement (QI) project designed to promote optimal care of children in all EDs. The primary purpose of Peds Ready is three-fold: (1) to establish a composite baseline of the nation's capacity to provide care to children in the ED, (2) to create a foundation for EDs to engage in an ongoing QI process that includes implementing the “Guidelines for the Care of Children in the Emergency Department,” and (3) to establish a benchmark that measures an ED's improvement overtime. More than 4,100 ED facilities (83% of America’s hospitals) participated in the assessment to determine their readiness to care for children. Visit the State Results Section for assessment results and project information.With the assessment completed, Peds Ready partners are active in phase two activities:
- the analysis of collected data,
- the dissemination and sharing of important data findings, and
- the creation of new and additional resources and tools to engage the health care community and effect change.
|
Inter-facility Transfer Processes
|
[Back to: Top] |
Research has shown outcomes for critically ill and injured children are optimized at hospitals having specific pediatric resources and expertise, such as a pediatric specific critical care area or pediatric intensive care unit (PICU). Yet, only 10% of all hospitals have PICUs. Scarcity of pediatric specific resources, including pediatric medical specialists for critically ill and injured children, requires today’s providers and medical systems to plan for inter-facility transport of pediatric and neonatal patients. More than 10,500 severely injured children were transferred to specialty care resources and services in 2012. Moving a very sick or critically injured infant or child from one facility to another facility is complex and stressful for the child, family, and staff. Preplanned processes reduce the strain of unfolding events, ensure that the handoff of the pediatric patient’s care is smooth, and increase transfer safety.
Guidelines and agreements for transfers of critically ill and injured children from receiving EDs to hospitals with specialty resources need to be well thought out, organized, and are essential for every hospital to have in place. Inter-facility transfer guidelines and agreements are encompassed in EMSC performance measures (#76 and #77, respectively) and are also identified in the Joint Policy Statement “Guidelines for Care of Children in the Emergency Department.”
Some states have well-defined regulations addressing the need for agreements for those services for which a hospital cannot provide care, such as burns. They may also require specific guidelines for the transfer, including pediatric patients. But these states are few and initial studies have found that even with these regulations or requirements in place, a lack of enforcement often limits the availability or efficacy of transfer guidelines and agreements. Systems of care focused on time sensitive diagnoses such as trauma, stroke, and STEMI may also require transfer guidelines and agreements since transfer to appropriate resources is typically a component of these systems. It may be feasible to build upon these specialty-care systems to establish universal hospital transfer processes that include pediatric patients or adjust the language to address patients of all ages. EMSC managers may also find it helpful to work with coordinators of these programs to identify practices facilitating availability of guidelines and agreements for transfer. For more information on inter-facility transfers, see the Inter Facility Transfer Toolkit for the Pediatric Patient.
|
ED Operations, Licensure, and Accreditation
|
[Back to: Top] |
Like prehospital EMS agencies, there are wide variations in the ways hospital and stand-alone EDs are accredited and licensed across states and territories. Many organizations and entities have a role in hospital regulation, licensing, and accreditation depending on the type and level(s) of service(s) provided. Hospital licensure and accreditation of EDs seldom resides in the same department or division as prehospital EMS systems and thus EMSC managers may need to collaborate and work with unfamiliar departments and hospital accreditation organizations to best understand systems of ED care in their states. The Pediatric Regionalization of Care Primer, Section 4: Hospital Regulations, Mandates, and Standards Influencing Regionalization, provides additional information to further your understanding of hospital operations.
|
EMSC Contributions to ED Hospital Care
|
[Back to: Top] |
For three decades, the EMSC Program has been a driving force in the ongoing efforts to improve pediatric emergency care across the continuum of care including the ED. The Program’s mission to assure that all children, no matter where they live, play or go to school, have access to high-quality emergency care continues to be a driving force for all involved in EMSC. EMSC performance measures specific to hospitals, as well as the National Pediatric Readiness Project, have defined specific recommendations and opportunities to improve the process for delivery of pediatric ED care. Since most EMSC managers are often within divisions/departments of EMS, the continuum of care focusing upon hospitals and EDs can be perceived as more difficult to address. However, State Partnership grantees across the country have worked with the hospitals and stakeholders in their states and territories to implement change and improvements and positively impact outcomes of pediatric emergency care. Periodic assessments of EMSC Program performance measures and hospital pediatric readiness are conducted. Upward trends of improvements are evident from this data (see Aggregate National Data for EMSC Performance Measures). Thus, state EMSC programs and their stakeholders can take credit for actualizing these improvements, but also know that opportunities for improvement continue to exist and their work is not done.
In 2013, the EMSC National Resource Center collaborated with ENA and the Society of Trauma Nurses (STN) to develop the Inter Facility Transfer Toolkit for the Pediatric Patient, a comprehensive resource to assure that hospitals and providers can better address important components of the transfer processes. Resources included in the toolkit support efforts in establishing agreements/memorandums of understanding to facilitate transfer of children to specialty resources when needed. Additionally, the toolkit aides in the development of pediatric transfer guidelines to assist staff as they work to ensure safe and timely inter facility transfer.
Other EMSC-funded initiatives impacting pediatric care in the ED include the Pediatric Emergency Care Applied Research Network (PECARN), Targeted Issue (TI), and State Partnership Regionalization of Care (SPROC) grant programs (see Section I for more information on these programs). To date, PECARN has published more than 100 manuscripts and/or abstracts providing a solid foundation for evidence-based pediatric emergency care in the ED. TI grants have also contributed a wealth of primary knowledge, as well as novel tools and resources to improve the care of children in the ED. Finally, the SPROC program brings both the performance measures and pediatric readiness together to facilitate development of regionalized pediatric systems of care for children and families in tribal, territorial, insular, and rural areas.
|
Where Hospital Systems are Headed
|
[Back to: Top] |
Dynamic changes in the U.S. healthcare system, underscored by passage of the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act, will have a major impact on hospitals and the broader systems of care in which they operate. Payment structures are now based on accountability, efficiency, and improved health outcomes. Greater transparency of physician and hospital outcomes data will continue to drive changes in delivery models for emergency care. Incentives to develop or enhance systems of care intended to deliver higher-quality care and lower costs, such as accountable care organizations and health care coalitions, will stimulate collaboration, coalition building, and regionalized systems of care. The use of telehealth and telemedicine will continue to expand with improvements in technology, changes in reimbursement policies, and increased pressure to reduce costs. As this technology advances and increases in use, the ability to provide pediatric specialty care should be enhanced. Finally, hospitals are continuing to move toward a system of electronic health data interoperability to provide safe, effective, efficient, and timely care with the most current patient information, as well as to vastly improve data for continued quality improvement and outcomes research.
1Weiss AJ, Wier LM, Stocks C, Blanchard J. Overview of Emergency Department Visits in the United States, 2011. HCUP Statistical Brief #174. Rockville, MD: Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality. 2014
2American Hospital Association. Fast Facts on US Hospitals. [Online]. Accessed February 24, 2015.
3U.S. Department of Health and human Services, Health Resources and Services Administration, Health Information Technology. What are critical access hospitals? [Online]. Accessed February 24, 2015.
4Cardiac centers are commonly referred to as STEMI centers for S-T Elevation Myocardial Infarction, a specific type of cardiac emergency that can be treated effectively with rapid treatment in a cardiac catheterization lab.