Table of Contents:
About Congress | The Public Policy Process | Influencing the Public Policy Process | Best Practices on Public Policy
The goal of the Emergency Medical Services for Children (EMSC) Program is to reduce child and youth mortality and morbidity resulting from severe illness or trauma. This can be achieved by standardizing protocols of pediatric emergency care and components of the pediatric emergency care infrastructure, offering public and professional education throughout the continuum of care, or conducting scientifically rigorous pediatric emergency care research and encouraging the development and use of evidence-based practices. To affect change on both a local and national level, however, individuals and organizations with a stake in pediatric emergency care must educate public officials about EMSC-related issues and priorities. Grantees’ participation in the decision-making process will raise the profile of EMSC and generate enthusiasm and support for system improvements.
This guide will help grantees navigate the world of public policymaking. Specifically, grantees will learn how Congress is structured, how a federal bill becomes law, and how the EMSC Program fits into the federal decision-making process. Second, grantees will learn how to directly affect change, including how to communicate with elected officials. Although this guide primarily focuses on the federal legislative process, much of the information, tools, and tips are applicable to the state and local policymaking processes.
About Congress
|
[Back to: Top] |
The House of Representatives and the Senate
The U.S. Congress was established by the Constitution as one of the three co-equal branches of the U.S. government. This legislative body is divided into two chambers: the House of Representatives, often referred to as the House, and the Senate. There are 435 voting members of the House, who are called Representatives or Congressmen and Congresswomen, and 100 voting members of the Senate, who are called Senators. Additionally, the House includes six non-voting members representing the District of Columbia and the territories of American Samoa, Guam, Northern Marianas Islands, Puerto Rico, and the U.S. Virgin Islands.
The number of Representatives serving in the House from any given state is determined in proportion to a state’s population, with each state apportioned at least one member. Each Representative is elected to serve a specific congressional district, or geographical area, within the state. In less populous states, the district may encompass the entire state. Districts are reapportioned every 10 years in accordance with population findings available from the U.S. Census. For example, after the 2010 Census, it was found that Illinois had lost population; therefore, the number of districts, and thus the number of Representatives, from the state decreased from 19 to 18.
While reapportionment can result in an increase or decrease in the number of Representatives from any given state, the total number of voting members of the House is set by law and cannot change from 435.
The number of Senators per state remains fixed at two, regardless of population. Unlike Representatives, Senators are elected to office to represent an entire state, not a district. Therefore, each Senator from any given state must answer to the entire state’s population.
The Legislative Cycle and Terms of Office
As previously noted, the term “Congress” can refer to the House of Representatives and the Senate combined. It can also be defined, however, as the two-year legislative period that occurs between elections.
Members of the House are elected to two-year terms, with each Representative up for reelection every two years, while members of the Senate are elected to six-year terms, with one-third of the Senators up for reelection every two years (see Table 1).
Between these biennial elections, Congress meets for a period of legislative activity. These periods are referred to by number and divided into two, one-year sessions; for example, the 113th Congress convened from January 2013 to December 2014, with the first session lasting from January 2013 to December 2013 and the second session lasting from January 2014 to December 2014. Bills that are introduced but not passed by Congress (the legislative body) within this two-year time frame must be reintroduced in the following Congress (the two-year legislative period).
Table 1: Terms of Office
| |
Voting Members |
Non-voting Members |
Represent |
Term of Office |
Electoral Cycle |
| House of Representatives |
435 |
6 |
districts, or a defined geographical area, within a state |
two-year term |
all up for reelection every two years |
| Senate |
100 |
0 |
state |
six-year term |
one-third up for reelection every two years |
Just as the legislative cycle changes with each election, so does the composition of Congress. Members of Congress may choose not to run for reelection or may lose to the opposing candidate. As a result, the number of Representatives and Senators affiliated with a specific political party may increase or decrease. The political party with the greatest number of members forms the majority party and the political party with the least number of members forms the minority party. This occurs individually in each chamber of Congress.
The majority party holds the most power in each respective chamber, controlling the legislative agenda, setting the legislative calendar, and filling committee chairmanships and other key leadership positions. The larger the majority is, the greater their ability to enact their agenda. Since both parties often have different priorities, however, if the majority party changes hands after an election, so may Congress’ priorities. This may increase or decrease the likelihood that particular legislation will be considered by Congress.
Leadership Positions and Committee Chairs
Congressional Committees with Jurisdiction over Health Care Issues
House of Representatives
House Committee on Energy and Commerce – This committee, and specifically the Subcommittee on Health, has jurisdiction over public health and quarantine; hospital construction; mental health; biomedical research and development; health information technology, privacy, and cybersecurity; public health insurance (Medicare, Medicaid) and private health insurance; medical malpractice and medical malpractice insurance; the regulation of food, drugs, and cosmetics; drug abuse; the Department of Health and Human Services; the National Institutes of Health; the Centers for Disease Control; Indian Health Service; and all aspects of the above-referenced jurisdiction related to the Department of Homeland Security.
House Committee on Ways and Means –
This committee, and specifically the Subcommittee on Health, has jurisdiction over federal programs providing payments for health care, health delivery systems, or health research. Popularly, the committee is known for having jurisdiction over Medicare.
Senate
Senate Committee on Health, Education, Labor, and Pensions –
This committee has jurisdiction over matters related to health, biomedical research and development, and public health. The committee has original jurisdiction over some of these matters; however, the Subcommittee on Primary Health and Aging is responsible for community health centers, The Health Resources and Services Act, oral health, health care disparities and Alzheimer’s disease.
Senate Committee on Finance –
This committee, and specifically the Subcommittee on Health Care, has jurisdiction over health programs under the Social Security Act and health programs financed by a specific tax or trust fund. Popularly, the committee is known for having jurisdiction over Medicare, Medicaid, and the Children’s Health Insurance Program.
|
Several key leadership positions exist within Congress, including Speaker of the House, House Majority Leader, House Minority Leader, Senate Majority Leader, and Senate Minority Leader. These individuals control the legislative agenda, set the legislative calendar, make committee assignments, and appoint committee chairman, among other duties (see Table 2).
According to the U.S. Constitution, the Vice President of the United States functions in the capacity as President of the Senate. While the role of the President of the Senate is primarily ceremonial, with rank and file Senators often presiding over the Senate in the Vice President’s place, the Vice President is called upon to cast his or her vote in the event of a tie. Also, in the event that membership in the Senate is split evenly among the political parties, such as with 50 Republican members and 50 Democratic members, the party of the Vice President would be considered the majority party.
Congress’ agenda is also influenced by the committee system. House and Senate committees are organized by and have jurisdiction over a specific subject area. For example, health care issues are considered by the House Committee on Energy and Commerce and the Senate Committee on Health, Education, Labor, and Pensions. Committees hold hearings to debate legislation, review the administration of existing federal programs, and investigate allegations of wrongdoing by public officials, among other responsibilities. Additionally, some committees are further divided into subcommittees that are focused on even more specific issues. For example, the House Committee on Energy and Commerce includes a Subcommittee on Health.
Taking into consideration their own legislative interests as well as the prestige of each committee, Members of Congress bid for committee assignments. Appointments are made by party leadership, with each party allotted a certain number of committee seats based on their status as the majority or minority. Typically, the most senior member of the majority party on the committee is appointed committee chair. Each chairman sets the agenda for his or her committee and decides what issues will be addressed and what bills will be considered. Therefore, as the chairmanship changes hands, so can the committee’s priorities. This may increase or decrease the likelihood that particular legislation will be considered by the committee.
Table 2: Leadership Positions
| |
Speaker of the House |
Majority Leader |
Minority Leader |
Majority and Minority Whip |
| House of Representatives |
- Leader of the House
- Sets the legislative agenda
- Presides over the House when in session
- Influences the selection of committee and subcommittee chairs
- Leader of the majority party in the House
- Elected to the position by his or her fellow majority members
- Second in the line of succession to the Presidency
- Position created by the Constitution and is unique to the House
|
- Second ranking official of the House
- Sets the schedule for consideration of legislation
- Responsible for the majority’s legislative strategy
- Promotes party unity
- Serves as a spokesperson for the majority
- Elected to the position by his or her fellow majority members
|
- Leader of the minority party in the House
- Responsible for the minority’s legislative strategy
- Promotes party unity
- Serves as a spokesperson for the minority
- Elected to the position by his or her fellow minority members
|
- Each party has its own whip
- Keeps tallies on how party members intend to vote on a piece of legislation
- Rallies party members to pass or defeat a piece of legislation
|
| Senate |
|
- Leader of the majority party in the Senate
- Sets the legislative agenda and schedule
- Responsible for the majority’s legislative strategy
- Promotes party unity
- Serves as a spokesperson for the majority
- Elected to the position by his or her fellow majority members
|
- Leader of the minority party in the Senate
- Responsible for the minority’s legislative strategy
- Promotes party unity
- Serves as a spokesperson for the minority
- Elected to the position by his or her fellow minority members
|
- Each party has its own whip
- Keeps tallies on how party members intend to vote on a piece of legislation
- Rallies party members to pass or defeat a piece of legislation
|
|
The Public Policy Process
|
[Back to: Top] |
The Federal Legislative Process
Both the House of Representatives and the Senate play an important role in the existence of all federal programs, including the EMSC Program. Congress follows a set procedure when considering federal legislation.
How a Bill Becomes a Law
Step 1 – Legislation is introduced in the House and/or Senate and assigned a number.
-
Any Member of Congress may introduce legislation, which is commonly referred to as a “bill.”
-
Each bill is assigned a number; this numbering system is sequential but distinct for the House and Senate.
-
Each bill number is preceded by “H.R.” in the House and “S.” in the Senate. H.R. stands for House Resolution.
Step 2 – Legislation is referred to the House or Senate committee of jurisdiction.
-
For example, an education bill would be referred to the committee handling education issues.
-
The bill can be further referred to a subcommittee; for example, a bill on elementary education might be referred to a subcommittee on elementary education.
| Key Committees Important to the EMSC Program |
|
| Senate – Committee on Health, Education, Labor, and Pensions (HELP), Subcommittee on Primary Care and Aging |
House – Committee on Energy and Commerce, Subcommittee on Health |
Step 3 – The House or Senate committee of jurisdiction may hold a hearing on the legislation and/or a “markup session,” during which it edits the bill. Ultimately, the committee votes on the bill and, if approved, reports it out, or passes it on, for consideration by the entire House or Senate.
-
Although most times the public can attend a committee hearing, they cannot make comments at the hearing. Only invited witnesses are allowed to testify on the bill for purposes of information.
-
If the committee does not report out the bill before the end of the two-year congressional session, the bill “dies.” To receive consideration again, the bill must be reintroduced in the next congressional session, where the process starts over again.
Step 4 – The House or Senate may debate, amend, and vote on the bill. If the bill passed on the floor of the House or Senate, it is referred to the other chamber for consideration. Unless the other chamber already has a similar measure under consideration, the bill is referred to committee.
-
If both the House and Senate do not debate and vote on the bill before the end of the two-year session, it dies.
-
If the bill is voted down by either chamber of Congress, the bill may die. Sometimes a bill is sent back to committee for further amending, after which it may be considered again on the floor.
Step 5 – If both the House and Senate pass the same bill, it is sent to the President for his signature.
-
If the House and Senate pass different versions of the bill, each chamber appoints members to a conference committee. The conference committee works out the differences between the two versions of the bill and drafts a “conference agreement” or compromise version of the bill. The House and Senate then vote on the conference agreement. If it passes both chambers, it is sent to the President for his signature.
Step 6 – The President either signs the bill into law or vetoes the bill.
-
If the President vetoes the bill, two-thirds of the House and Senate can vote to override the President’s veto. If the veto is overridden, the bill becomes law.
Authorizing Legislation
For a federal program to exist, Congress must approve a program’s authorization as well as its annual federal appropriation. Legislative committees are responsible for authorizing legislation related to the agencies and programs under their jurisdiction. The appropriations committees of the House and Senate have jurisdiction over appropriations measures.
Authorizing legislation establishes a federal agency or program and provides guidance regarding the appropriate amount of funds needed to carry out the authorized activities of the agency or program. However, authorizing legislation does not provide the funding itself or guarantee that the program will be funded will be at that level through the federal appropriations process.
Authorizing legislation not only establishes a program in name, but it also delineates in statute what a program is and it is not allowed to do. This is often referred to as a program’s scope of authority. For example, the legislation authorizing the EMSC Program defines the entities eligible to receive EMSC grants (states/territories or academic medical centers), the duration of each grant, and how many EMSC grants a state may receive at one time.
Federal programs, including the EMSC Program, are usually authorized to exist for a finite amount of time, typically three to five years, at which time Congress must renew the program’s authorization through the legislative process. This is commonly referred to as “reauthorization.” Congress can make changes to a program’s scope of authority when it is reauthorized.
Federal Budget and Appropriations
While authorizing legislation recommends funding levels for federal agencies and programs, it does not provide funding itself. Actual program funding is accomplished through the federal budget and appropriations process.
Congress must complete the budget and appropriations process each federal fiscal year; the federal fiscal year begins on October 1 and ends on September 30 (see Diagram 1). This means that, as a general rule, federal agencies and programs receive funding one year at a time. The amount of funding a program receives can change from year to year, depending upon how much money Congress decides to allocate to it. Based upon federal policy and budget priorities, a program may receive a funding increase, a funding decrease, or level funding.
In theory, federal agencies and programs must be authorized in order to receive an annual appropriation. In practice, however, Congress regularly appropriates funding to programs whose authorization has expired. It may take Congress several years to reauthorize a program through the legislative process; during this time, Congress often chooses to continue funding the program, despite the fact that its authorization has lapsed.
The Budget and Appropriations Process
Step 1 – The President’s Budget. Each year, on or before the first Monday in February, the President releases his budget request for the upcoming fiscal year (FY). For example, the FY 2016 (October 1, 2015 to September 30, 2016) budget was released in February 2015. The President’s budget is a non-binding proposal that sets forth the executive branch’s budget priorities and contains detailed funding recommendations for federal agencies and programs for the next fiscal year. It does not have the force of law and does not appropriate funding.
Step 2 – The Congressional Budget Resolution. Each year, Congress drafts a budget resolution, which outlines its financial priorities for the coming fiscal year and sets general spending limits on federal activities. For example, the resolution sets a spending limit for the entire Department of Health and Human Services; it does not recommend specific funding levels for individual programs within the department, such as the EMSC Program. These spending limits serve as a fiscal guideline for the federal appropriations process.
The congressional budget resolution often varies from the President’s budget request. Although Congress votes on the budget resolution, typically in April, it is not signed into law by the President.
Step 3 – The Appropriations Process. Appropriations bills provide funding for federal agencies and programs. Each fiscal year, Congress considers approximately 12 appropriations bills; a single appropriations bill may provide funding for multiple agencies and programs (e.g., the Departments of Labor-Health and Human Services-Education (L-HHS) appropriations bill funds programs within those three departments). The total amount Congress can appropriate to all federal agencies and programs within a given department is defined by the congressional budget resolution's spending limits.
In considering the L-HHS appropriations bill, which includes funding for the EMSC Program, Congress follows a slightly varied legislative process.
Step A – The L-HHS Subcommittee of the House Appropriations Committee introduces the appropriations bill. The Subcommittee marks-up, or edits, the bill. The Subcommittee then votes on the bill and reports it, or passes it on, to the full House Appropriations Committee. This process is supposed to begin in May.
Step B – The House Appropriations Committee marks-up, or edits, the bill. The Committee then votes on the bill and reports it to the House of Representatives.
Step C – The House debates, amends, and votes on the bill. If the bill is passed, it is referred to the Senate, specifically to the L-HHS Subcommittee of the Senate Appropriations Committee. This is supposed to be completed by June.
Step D – The Senate Subcommittee marks-up, or edits, the bill. The Subcommittee then votes on the bill and reports it to the full Senate Appropriations Committee.
Step E – The Senate Appropriations Committee marks-up, or edits, the bill. The Committee then votes on the bill and reports it to the Senate.
Step F – The Senate debates, amends, and votes on the bill.
Step G – If both the House and Senate pass the same version of the bill, it is sent to the President for his signature.
If the House and Senate pass different versions of the bill, which is often the case, each chamber appoints members to a conference committee. The conference committee works out the differences between the two versions of the bill and produces a conference agreement (a final, compromise version of the bill). The House and Senate then vote on the conference agreement. If it passes, it is sent to the President for his signature.
Step H – The President either signs the bill into law, ideally in time for the beginning of the fiscal year on October 1, or he vetoes the bill.
If the President vetoes the bill, two-thirds of the House and Senate can vote to override the President’s veto. If the veto is overridden, the bill becomes law. If the veto is not overridden, Congress must revise the bill and send the revised version to the President.
Again, appropriations bills are the one legislative item that must be enacted each year. Since federal agencies and programs receive funding one fiscal year at a time, they would shut down if they did not receive an appropriation before the beginning of the next fiscal year.
Many times, however, all of the appropriations bills are not signed into law by the beginning of the fiscal year on October 1. In this situation, Congress may pass a continuing resolution (CR). A CR funds agencies and programs, usually at the previous year’s level, for a defined amount of time or until the appropriations bills are enacted.
Tracking Federal Legislation
The public may track federal legislation through the Library of Congress-administered U.S. federal legislation information website. The database houses all bills that have been introduced in the current two-year session of Congress. Legislation introduced in past two-year sessions of Congress can also be found by selecting ‘All Legislation’ from the left search box’s drop down menu.
For example, H.R. 4290, the Wakefield Act, a bill reauthorizing the EMSC Program introduced in the 113th Congress, can be found using the following steps:
-
Access the U.S. federal legislation information website available.
-
Select "All Legislation" from the left search box's drop down menu
-
In the right search box, enter:
-
H.R. 4290” to search by bill number,
-
Wakefield Act” to search by bill title, or
-
Emergency Medical Services for Children” to search by key word.
-
When redirected, select the resulting bill that was introduced in the 113th Congress, as indicated.
After selecting the legislation in question, individuals will be redirected to a page with information on the bill’s summary and status, including the text of the legislation; the names of any cosponsors; and a list of all Congressional action. This information is updated as the bill passes through the legislative process.
Once initial results are retrieved, the search can be refined by source (e.g., legislation, Congressional Record, or committee report), two-year session of Congress, bill type, status of legislation, subject, chamber, committee, and bill sponsor or cosponsor, among other factors. These options may be selected from the menu boxes on the left hand side of the results page. For more information on conducting searches, select "Tips" to the right of the search boxes on the top of the http://congress.gov homepage.
Note that when looking for the text of any legislation, several versions of the bill may be presented. In order of advancement through the legislative process, these include:
Introduced – The version of the bill as introduced in either the House or the Senate.
Reported – The version of the bill as considered and passed by the committee to which it was referred.
Engrossed – The version of the bill as debated and passed by either the House or the Senate.
Referred – The version of the bill as referred to the House or Senate after passage by the other chamber.
Enrolled – The version of the bill as passed in identical form by both the House and Senate and sent to the President for his signature.
Be sure to choose the correct version. When in doubt, select the most recent version, which is usually the last one listed.
The Federal Regulatory Process
Complementing the federal legislative process is the federal regulatory process. Congress sometimes passes laws that purposefully lack detail, leaving it to the various executive branch agencies to issue rules and regulations defining how the laws are to be implemented. For example, Congress may pass a law giving the Department of Health and Human Services broad authority to improve vision care for newborns; the Department then drafts specific initiatives to improve such care.
Executive agencies publish proposed regulations in the Federal Register and allow for a public comment period. At the end of that period, an agency will consider the comments and publish a final regulation on the issue. Note that Congress can overturn a regulation through the legislative process within 60 days of it being made final.
The State Legislative and Regulatory Process
EMSC State Partnership grantees are required to meet several federal performance measures. Measure 80 requires that EMSC priorities be integrated into state mandate (e.g., state statute, regulation, or other policy). Having a basic understanding of the state legislative and regulatory process is the first step towards successfully meeting this measure.
State governments function similarly to the federal government, operating with legislative, executive, and judicial branches; the former two are most important in supporting the state’s EMSC Program. The activities of these branches are regulated by a state constitution and therefore differ from state to state. While general information on state legislative and executive branches is outlined below, consider speaking with a state department chief or the department’s legal counsel or an academic institution chief or institution’s legal counsel for more information on a state’s specific legislative and regulatory processes.
State Legislative Branch
All states but one have legislatures that are bicameral, or that consist of two chambers: the House of Representatives, sometimes referred to as the House of Delegates or the Assembly, and the Senate. Legislators may be called Representatives, Delegates, Assemblymen and Assemblywoman, or Senators. Only Nebraska’s legislature is unicameral, consisting of one chamber with all members referred to as Senators.
States follow a legislative process very similar to that of the federal government. Legislators introduce bills, which are then referred to and considered by a relevant committee. After committee approval, the bill must be considered by both legislative chambers. If both chambers pass the same version of the bill, it is presented to the Governor.
Most state legislatures' websites include a tool that allows the public to track state legislation. To locate a state legislature’s website, search for ‘name of state’ and ‘legislature,’ ‘House,’ ‘Assembly,’ or ‘Senate.’ Note that if searching by ‘name of state’ and ‘legislature’, the result may be the homepage for the House, the Senate, or both.
On the homepage, find the menu option or search tool titled “legislation,” “bill search,” “bill lookup,” “bill finder,” or something similar. Some sites allow searches for legislation by year, bill name, bill number, or keyword. Keep in mind that a website for a state House may only store information on legislation introduced in that chamber; the opposite may hold true for a state Senate website. Therefore, in order to track legislation introduced in the both the House and the Senate, search for, find, and visit the websites for both chambers.
State Executive Branch
The executive branch is run by a Governor, who, as the chief executive officer of the state government, oversees numerous agencies, commissions, and boards. As with the federal system, state legislation is approved or vetoed by the Governor.
The executive branch also oversees the state regulatory process. As with the federal legislature, state legislatures sometimes pass laws that are purposefully lacking in detail, leaving it to the state’s various executive branch agencies to come up with the specifics of the law through rules and regulations. For example, a state legislature may pass a law giving the state’s Department of Health broad authority to improve vision care for newborns; the department then drafts specific initiatives to improve such care.
Executive agencies publish proposed regulations in a public document, sometimes called a register or administrative bulletin, and allow for a public comment period. (To locate an online version of this document, search for “name of state” and “administrative register,” “government register,” or “administrative bulletin.”) At the end of this period, an agency will consider the comments and publish a final regulation on the issue. Note that state legislatures may be able to overturn a regulation through the legislative process.
Influencing The Public Policy Process
|
[Back to: Top] |
Prohibition on Lobbying with Federal Grant Dollars
To lobby is to seek to influence the introduction, passage, amendment, or defeat of legislation. Keep in mind that federal law prohibits federal grantees, including EMSC grantees, from using their grant dollars to lobby legislators. Using grant dollars means a grantee cannot lobby during work hours; identify him/herself as acting, writing, or speaking on behalf of the grant program when lobbying on personal or non-EMSC funded work time; or use resources and supplies (e.g., a computer or telephone) paid for solely with grant dollars to assist with lobbying activities that occur on personal or non-EMSC funded time.
Two main types of lobbying, both of which are prohibited under the law, include:
| Direct Lobbying |
Grassroots Lobbying |
| Direct lobbying is any attempt to influence legislators in the introduction, passage, amending, or defeat of legislation through personal contact. Direct lobbying activities may include written correspondence with, telephone calls to, or a face-to-face meeting with a legislator or the legislator’s employee. Other examples of direct lobbying include providing testimony on legislation before a committee or subcommittee and preparing a written report or fact sheet that includes an opinion in support of or against legislation. |
Grassroots lobbying is any attempt to encourage the general public to influence legislators in the introduction, passage, amending, or defeat of legislation. |
For more information, see Attachment B, Section 25 of Office of Management and Budget Circular No. A-122.
Acceptable Communication with Policymakers
While it is imperative that EMSC grantees follow these rules, they are not meant to bar participation in the public policy process. EMSC grantees may communicate with legislators by following the general guidelines provided below. Keep in mind that grantees may be further limited by rules established by their employer. Be sure to understand the employer’s limitations and adhere to their guidelines for lobbying activities.
Educating and Informing versus Lobbying
Grantees can participate in the legislative process during EMSC-paid work hours by educating and informing their legislators. When educating and informing, grantees are not expressing a view about legislation and are not asking a legislator to introduce, support, or oppose legislation. Instead, grantees are strictly providing factual information on a particular topic. Examples of educating and informing include:
-
providing factual information on a particular topic to help policymakers or the general public form an independent opinion about the topic;
-
providing factual testimony or technical advice and assistance to a committee or subcommittee, when invited to do so; and
-
communicating with government officials for purposes other than influencing legislation, such as commenting on regulations.
IMPORTANT: Before conducting activities designed to educate and inform, grantees should check with their employer to be sure they do not have limitations on such activities.
Grantees Whose Salaries are Paid in Part by non-EMSC Program Funds
Grantees who work full-time but whose salaries are paid in part by their employer may be able to lobby during their non-EMSC working hours. For example, if 20 percent of a grantee’s salary is paid for by a medical center, then 20 percent of that person’s work time may be used to lobby for the center. A grantee must identify him/herself as an employee of the medical center when conducting these activities; do not identify yourself as acting, writing, or speaking on behalf of the grant or use resources solely paid for with grant dollars to assist with lobbying activities (e.g., a computer or telephone).
IMPORTANT: The institution paying part of a grantee’s salary may have its own rules regarding allowable lobbying activities. It is important to check what limitations exist before engaging in such activities.
Lobbying as a Private Citizen
A grantee may lobby on any legislation on his/her own time as a private citizen as long as he/she does not use federal grant resources. Again, be sure to keep the following in mind:
-
Do not identify yourself as acting, writing, or speaking on behalf of an EMSC grant.
-
Do not use state EMSC program letterhead or your employee email account when writing to legislators.
-
Do not write, e-mail, or call during EMSC-paid work hours.
-
Do not use employees of the grant during paid work time to prepare lobbying materials.
-
Do not use any resources or supplies paid for solely with grant dollars (e.g., a computer or telephone).
Lobbying as a Member of a Professional Organization
If a grantee is a member of a professional or other interest-oriented organization -- such as the Emergency Nurses Association, the National Association of EMTs, or Family Voices – he/she may be able to lobby on any legislation representing him/herself as a member of that organization. Before doing so, check with the organization to ensure the activities comply with their own priorities and practices. Remember, EMSC grantees must lobby on their own time in that group’s name, not the grant’s name or with grant resources.
Identifying Federal Legislators
To effectively communicate with federal legislators, know who they are.
| Identifying Representatives |
Identifying Senators |
1. Go to the “Find Your Representative” page on the the U.S. House of Representatives website.
|
1. Go to the “Senators” page on the U.S. Senate website.
|
| 2. Enter your zip code in the search box and click on "Find Your Rep by Zip" |
2. From the "Choose a State" drop down menu, select a state to be redirected to a page that lists the names of both senators, as well as the address and phone number of their Washington, DC, offices. Link to each Senator's website by clicking on their respective names. |
| 3. A page that includes the name of the Representative, as well as the addresses, phone numbers, and fax numbers for his or her offices will be displayed. Link to the Representative’s website by clicking on his or her name.
|
|
Note: If the name of the Representative is already known, access his or her website directly by visiting the website of the U.S. House of Representatives, and choosing his or her name from the "Representatives' Web sites" drown down menu. Locate his or her contact information in the appropriate section on his or her website.
Those without internet access should be able to identify their legislators by searching the government section of the phone book or consulting one of many congressional directories, which can be found at a local library. Another option is to contact the U.S. Capitol Switchboard at (202) 224-3121; operators should be able to hela nameentify legislators and will transfer calls to a legislator's office.
Legislators maintain a Washington, DC, office and one or more offices within their districts or states. When discussing federal legislative issues with Senators and Representatives, contact their Washington, DC, offices. District offices generally assist constituents having problems with federal agencies, such as a lost Social Security check or delays in obtaining a visa, and handle community outreach activities, such as town hall meetings or visits to local businesses.
Being an Informed Constituent
One of the greatest benefits of communicating with legislators is the opportunity to build mutually beneficial, professional relationships with them and their staff. First, however, grantees must earn their respect and trust as an informed constituent. This is easily accomplished by conducting a little research prior to the visit, telephone call, email, or letter.
Knowing the background and legislative interests of a Member of Congress is of critical importance, especially for an in-person meeting, as it will help determine if the legislator has a personal or professional interest in a particular issue. Each legislator’s website will likely contain press releases, lists of bills sponsored or cosponsored, committee and caucus assignments, and other information that will reveal their legislative stance. For example, if a Representative serves on the House Energy and Commerce Committee, which has jurisdiction over EMSC, it would increase their stake in the Program. If he or she is a member of the Congressional Children’s Health Caucus or introduced legislation related to children’s health that would indicate he or she may be sympathetic to the issue of EMSC.
Biographical or other personal information posted on his or her website can be just as telling. In terms of EMSC, he or she may be a board member at a local children’s hospital; be a physician, nurse, or other health care professional by training; or may reveal some other piece of personal information that indicates where his or her interests lie.
It is also important to understand where Congress and others stand on the issue in which you are interested. Research whether or not legislation has been introduced on the topic; if so, know whether or not the legislator has cosponsored the bill and where the bill is in the legislative process. Learn which groups or influential individuals support or oppose the issue and why. If there is something you do not know, do not be afraid to admit it, but be sure to follow-up with the information.
IMPORTANT: Remember that grantees may only provide factual information on a particular topic. They may not express a view about legislation or ask a legislator to introduce, support, or oppose legislation.
Communicating with legislators for the first time can be a daunting task. Keep in mind, however, that for the most part legislators are generalists, meaning they know a little about a lot of issues. They rely upon others to provide them with the specifics on any given topic. When it comes to pediatric emergency medical care, a grantee, a practicing health care professional, or a family member of a child who uses the EMS system, is the expert. Talk about the difference EMSC has made in the state, to patients, or in the family. This will help you gain the legislator’s respect and trust in you as an informed constituent.
Types of Communication
The easiest means of communicating with a legislator is by telephone, email, and writing letters; however, scheduling an in-person meeting can have the greatest impact. Each of these options is discussed below.
Telephone Calls
Telephone calls are an efficient way of sharing information related to a particular issue. When calling, ask to speak to the legislator or the staff member who handles health care issues. More than likely grantees will be asked to leave a message with whomever answers the phone.
Keep the message brief and specific, and if calling about particular legislation, mention the bill number or title. Provide a personal perspective; do not simply read talking points or from a “script.” Members of Congress and their staff are more likely to provide a thoughtful response to a thoughtful message.
When calling, identify yourself as a constituent, as Members of Congress tend to respond only to those they represent. If speaking to the legislator or to the staff member who handles health care issues, be sure to thank him or her for his or her time and consider following up with a thank you email or letter. Consider sending the legislator or staff member additional information, if appropriate.
Letters versus Electronic Mail
Legislators receive a large amount of mail. All mail sent to the U.S. Congress is irradiated, leading to a delay in delivery. Therefore, unless it is absolutely necessary, email is the preferred communication vehicle.
Although emails or letters are less personal than a telephone call or in-person meeting, they can be very influential if they are thoughtful and well written. Remember to keep the message clear and concise, and try not to address more than one issue per letter or email. As with telephone calls, if writing about particular legislation, be sure to mention the bill number or title. Finally, close the letter/email by thanking the legislator for his or her attention.
Sometimes organizations will circulate a form letter or email on a given subject where the sender simply fills in the name of his/her legislator in the salutation and signs his/her name. Avoid using these templates if at all possible,. Either write a separate letter or email or edit the template to include personal points of view. Legislators will appreciate letters or emails that share personal thoughts and experience.
When addressing a letter or email, be respectful of the office the legislator holds and use the proper salutation and address (see Table 3). In return, the sender should provide his or her name and contact information so that the legislator may return the correspondence. Note that many legislators respond only to correspondence from their constituents, or those living in their state or legislative district.
Table 3: Addressing Federal Legislators
| Representatives |
Senators |
The Honorable ________
United States House of Representatives
Washington, DC 20510
Dear Representative ________: |
The Honorable ________
United States Senate
Washington, DC 20515
Dear Senator ________: |
In-Person Meeting
Suggested Group Members for A Legislative Visit
- State chapter of the American Academy of Pediatric or physician with pediatric training;
- State chapter of the American College of Emergency Physicians or an emergency physician;
- State chapter of Emergency Nurses Association or nurse with emergency pediatric experience;
- State chapter of the Society of Trauma Nurses or a nurse with trauma experience;
- Emergency medical technician (EMT) or paramedic, possibly a member of the National Association of EMTs;
- State or local ambulance association representative;
- State or local coalition of Safe Kids USA or injury prevention specialist;
- School nurse;
- Parent teacher association representative;
- Hospital association and local or State children’s hospital representative;
- Individual or association with expertise in pediatric disaster preparedness;
- All EMSC grant recipients within the State – State Partnership Principal Investigator, Grant Manager, and Family Representative; Targeted Issues Principal Investigator, if applicable; PECARN members, if applicable;
- State EMS agency representatives, including the EMS medical director, EMS administrator, trauma manager, and EMS training representative; and
- Public safety representatives, including highway safety representative, police representative, and fire-based EMS representative.
|
A personal meeting with a legislator is perhaps the most effective way to convey a message. If a legislator is unavailable, ask to meet with the staff member responsible for health care issues. Do not underestimate the importance of a meeting with a legislative aide. While they are often young, they are usually intelligent, motivated, and capable. They conduct research, draft legislation, write speeches, and brief officials on a regular basis. In short, legislators rely upon them when making policy decisions.
As previously mentioned, being an informed constituent is critical to the success of a meeting. When speaking to a legislator or his or her aide, be clear and concise. Most in-person meetings are short, no longer than15 minutes, be sure you are prepared to convey your message and leave time for discussion within that timeframe. Be prepared to answer questions. If you are unable to answer a specific question, do not be afraid to admit it, but be sure to follow-up with the information.
In the case of EMSC, mention how the federal grant has benefited pediatric emergency medical care within the legislator’s state. Thank the legislator for his support of the Program in general and your work in particular, if applicable.
In addition, prepare an information kit to leave with the legislator. This could include, but not be limited to, fact sheets, national and local statistics, and articles. Be sure to include a business card or contact information. Legislators and their staff have busy schedules and often take many meetings throughout the day; leaving materials will help ensure that your concerns are not forgotten.
Working with a Group
To increase the impact of a message, consider visiting the policymaker as part of a group. In the case of EMSC, state advisory committee members may be willing, and able, to assist in these efforts and will add additional viewpoints. Group members with a wide breadth of backgrounds and experience provide a more complete picture of the issue and a more accurate representation of the number and types of individuals with a stake in EMSC (see “Suggested Group Members for a Legislative Visit”). For example, the skills and experience of a physician or nurse can help accurately emphasize the clinical importance of EMSC while a family representative can speak very personally of the benefit of improved pediatric emergency care. Such personal stories often are more compelling than facts and figures.
Tips and Tactics For Educating and Informing Legislators
General Tips:
-
Do not assume that the legislator or aide is familiar with EMSC activities. Remember, you are the expert.
-
Keep the message short and simple.
-
Always be respectful and courteous, even if the legislator’s actions run contrary to personal belief.
Tips for Telephone Calls, Emails, and Letters:
-
Make sure your name and address are clearly written in the email or letter.
-
Make sure to provide your name and contact information on the telephone call.
-
Ask for a response in which the legislator’s position or action is stated.
Tips for In-Person Meetings:
-
Schedule an appointment with the legislator regarding EMSC grant activities. If the legislator is not available, request an appointment with the staff member responsible for health care issues. Most of the information that a legislator relies on comes from his/her staff, therefore it is important to convince the aide to see things your way.
-
Before a visit, research the legislator (e.g., party affiliation, committee assignments, legislative interests, personal or professional affiliations).
-
Prepare a fact sheet or compile other information on EMSC grant activities to leave with the legislator or aide.
-
Be prompt – a few minutes early, if possible.
-
Do not assume that the legislator or aide is familiar with EMSC activities. Discuss the value of the state’s EMSC program, its accomplishments to date, and the difference the program has made in the state’s system of care for children. The basic message is that EMSC grant activities are improving the health and well-being of all children by addressing the special needs of children.
-
Plan what will be said in advance, keeping the message simple, direct, and brief.
-
Prepare a condensed version of key points in case the meeting time gets cut short.
-
If visiting with a legislator as a group, designate a chief spokesperson and an order of speaking. Ensure that all members of the group have a role. Plan in advance what each person will say to ensure consistency and avoid repetition.
-
Lead with a personal story; tell the legislator or aide what EMSC means to you, your family, and your community.
-
Listen carefully to the legislator’s comments and questions.
-
Take brief notes on any questions that went unanswered for future follow up.
-
Ask for a response in which the legislator’s position or action is stated.
-
After the visit, write a thank you note, and follow-up with requested information.
Best Practices on Public Policy
|
[Back to: Top] |
Perhaps the best way to understand the public policy process is to engage in it. Listed below are two examples from EMSC grantees on affecting policy change.
Washington, DC EMSC State Partnership Grant Manager
Cynthiana Lightfoot, NREMT-P is the EMSC State Partnership Grant project manager for Washington, DC. She formerly served as the District’s EMSC family representative. DC EMSC, as it is known, has had the privilege of testifying before the DC City Council on prioritizing pediatric needs in emergency care. In addition, Ms. Lightfoot has been invited to testify before the council regarding Automated External Defibrillators (AEDs) and car booster seat safety. While testifying before legislators can be a daunting experience, Ms. Lightfoot has learned a few rules that can make the experience seamless and rewarding. These rules include:
-
EMSC grantees must learn “the rules” of advocacy. If a grantee's salary is paid for entirely by a federal grant, he/she will only be able to testify as a content expert when invited to do so by a legislative committee, council, or other legislative body. A content expert is someone who simply shares his or her knowledge on a particular issue. They cannot speak in support of or against a specific piece of legislation. Family representatives, EMSC advisory committee members, and others whose salary is not paid for by grant dollars may be able to take a stand on a legislative issue. These individuals should be used to supplement or enhance testimony.
-
To become a content expert first form a relationship with your policymakers. In DC, Ms. Lightfoot made appointments with city council members and/or their staff and educated them about her issues of interest. In the states, grantees should identify the legislators who serve on the committees that have jurisdiction over their issues of interest. An initial meeting with a legislator can be as simple as introducing yourself, thanking the legislator for his or her service, and informing them about your issue. Continue to contact your legislator on a regular basis; following up on any outstanding issues from your initial meeting, providing him or her with information on your issue or updates on your activities, or thanking him or her for supporting children’s issues. Over time a mutually beneficial relationship will be established.
-
Working with a coalition can increase the impact of your testimony. When working on car booster seat safety, Ms. Lightfoot met with Safe Kids USA and other injury prevention groups, the DC Department of Transportation, and Children’s National Medical Center to determine a plan to advance the issue. Whether a member of a professional (e.g., a physicians or nurses association), consumer (e.g., Family Voices or the PTA), or injury prevention organization (e.g., Safe Kids USA), or volunteer at a local school or hospital, these groups can provide grantees with an introduction to their legislators and help them prepare their testimony.
-
When preparing testimony, know the maximum length of time allowed to testify. At both the federal and state level, this can be as short as three to five minutes. Given the potential time constraints, it is imperative to prepare a concise statement, focusing on three or four main points. When testifying on AEDs, for example, Ms. Lightfoot focused on the public health outcome of the use of AEDs as well as the legislative and fiscal outcomes of the council passing legislation related to defibrillators. To supplement her oral testimony, she also prepares written testimony that is submitted to the council and entered into the record. Since written testimony is usually longer in length than oral testimony, use it to expand upon the points in the oral statement.
Challenges
-
Legislators do not always have a sufficient understanding of children’s needs and priorities.
-
Working with a group can be beneficial, but make sure members of the group do not lose focus and prioritize their individual needs above those of the group.
Lessons Learned
-
Content experts must always be learning. Do not rely on your current level of expertise. Do your homework and your research.
-
Make sure that the legislator that is presenting your issue or bill at a legislative hearing has the information needed to understand the issue. Consider writing a brief introduction for him or her that explains both the issue and any related legislation.
-
Review any budget concerns and know if the legislation has any fiscal impact. In short, know your numbers and be prepared to discuss this aspect.
-
After a bill you have supported is introduced in the legislature or brought up for a committee or council hearing, thank everyone involved and be present for the hearing, even if you are not testifying.
-
Aim to secure as many legislators in support of your issue or bill as possible. Do not rely on one champion.
-
Testifying on an issue is only part of the process. To truly impact change, be involved from before legislation is introduced until after it becomes law.
While testifying before legislators can be a daunting experience, Ms. Lightfoot would like to share a few rules she has learned that can make the experience seamless and rewarding.
-
Advertise your expertise. Even if your salary is paid for entirely by a federal grant, you can still take part in the public policy process. Make it known that you are available to serve as a content expert. A content expert is someone who simply shares his or her knowledge on a particular issue. Content experts cannot speak in support of or against a specific piece of legislation. In DC, Ms. Lightfoot made appointments with city council members and/or their staff and educated them about her issues of interest. It wasn’t long after that she was invited by a legislative committee to serve as a content expert.
-
Make use of family representatives, EMSC advisory committee members, and others whose salary is not paid for by grant dollars. They may be able to take a stand on a legislative issue; supplementing or enhancing a grantee’s testimony.
-
Work with a coalition to further your legislative pursuits. When working on car booster seat safety, Ms. Lightfoot met with Safe Kids USA and other injury prevention groups, the DC Department of Transportation, and Children’s National Medical Center to determine a plan to advance the issue. Whether you are a member of a professional (e.g., a physicians or nurses association), consumer (e.g., Family Voices or the PTA), or injury prevention organization (e.g., Safe Kids USA), or volunteer at a local school or hospital, these groups can introduce you to legislators and help prepare testimony.
-
Supplement oral testimony with a written statement. At both the federal and state levels, the time allotted for your testimony can be as short as three to five minutes. Given the potential time constraints, Ms. Lightfoot found that it is imperative to prepare a concise statement, focusing on three or four main points. To supplement her oral testimony, she also prepares written testimony that is submitted to the council and entered into the record. Since written testimony is usually longer in length than oral testimony, grantees should use it to expand upon the points in your oral statement.
Tennessee EMSC Program Executive Director
As executive director of Tennessee’s EMSC program, Rhonda G. Phillippi, RN, BA, has had several years of experience in meeting with her policymakers on issues related to improving pediatric emergency medical care. Until recently, Ms. Phillippi's position was funded 100 percent by federal dollars, so she focused her efforts on educating and informing. She meets with as many members of the Tennessee congressional delegation as possible, both Senators and Representatives, and has found that while meeting with the legislator can be rewarding, meeting with each legislator’s health care aide is the most productive use of time.
Even if a grantee is permitted to lobby because his/her position is paid for, in part, by non-Federal dollars, Ms. Phillippi believes that educating and informing legislators can be an invaluable learning experience. Use the time to build relationships with the policymaker and his/her staff. Become a trusted expert before “asking” or “lobbying” them to take a stance on an issue.
Through her efforts, Ms. Phillippi has learned the value of working with a group. She invites the EMSC grant's principal investigator, physicians, and a PTA representative or a consumer, among others, to accompany her on each legislative visit and attempts to recruit these individuals from different parts of the state. Each person brings a varying perspective to the table and may be able to lobby even when a grantee cannot.
In advance of each legislative visit, Ms. Phillippi meets with the group to ensure that everyone understands the issue being discussed, their role in the process, and the desired outcome. She also confers with other organizations that have an interest in EMSC, such as the American Academy of Pediatrics. These organizations may be able to provide additional information related to the cause and help craft a clear, unified message. She emphasizes that the message does not need to be complex; keep points brief.
At each visit, Ms. Phillippi begins by thanking the legislator and his/her staff for taking the time to meet with the group, provides background information on her organization and their interests, explains what the state has been able to accomplish with federal EMSC funding, and talks about the positive difference EMSC has made for children across the country. She stresses that the money the state receives is being put to good use. Ms. Phillippi makes a special point of thanking each policymaker for supporting EMSC. She noted that legislators are often pleasantly surprised by this, as many of them have indicated that few people make an effort simply to thank them.
Oftentimes, the legislator or a staff member will ask a question that Ms. Phillippi and her colleagues can’t answer. When this occurs, be forthright and say that you don’t have an answer, but will look into it. As soon as possible, send the requested information in an email, once again taking the opportunity to thank the legislator or staff member for taking the time to meet with the group. Follow up with a telephone call to ensure the office received the information.
Ms. Phillippi's experience in educating and informing has provided her with many chances to help change the pediatric emergency care infrastructure across the United States. Although grantees may have limited time to meet with their policymakers, that time is crucial. Each telephone call, letter, email, and office visit is beneficial to the grantee, to the constituents, to the program and to the issue.
Challenges
-
Be proactive, especially when dealing with logistics, such as scheduling appointments.
-
A legislator often changes his/her priorities from season to season. Even though he/she may be a champion of an issue one year, the following year may be different. This does not mean the legislator is opposed to the issue, just that it is not a top priority for the current legislative session.
Lessons Learned
-
Be flexible. A legislator's schedule often changes. Don’t get disappointed if a meeting is cancelled or delayed. Note that not every legislator will agree to an office visit.
-
Even if a grantee is new to EMSC, more than likely he/she will know more about the issues being discussed than will the legislators and their staff.
-
Most legislative office visits are limited to 5 to 15 minutes. Make those minutes count by planning carefully and using your resources and experts wisely.
-
Educating and informing is just as important as “lobbying.” It only takes one office visit, one telephone call, or one email to get the process started.